Does a Care Home Need Professional Indemnity Insurance?

Doug Walsh

24/8/2026

Care Insurance

Professional indemnity (PI) insurance is an important cover for many professions, but for most care homes, nursing homes and domiciliary care providers, it isn't typically the protection they need. That's because the risks faced by care providers are very different from those faced by businesses that primarily offer professional advice. Instead, specialist care insurance policies are designed to protect against the operational and clinical risks that arise when delivering care.

What Is Professional Indemnity Insurance?

Professional indemnity insurance protects businesses that provide professional advice or specialist services.

If incorrect advice, recommendations or professional services result in a financial loss for a client, professional indemnity insurance can help cover legal costs and compensation.

It's commonly purchased by:

  • Accountants
  • Solicitors
  • Architects
  • Financial advisers
  • Consultants
  • Surveyors

For these professions, the primary risk lies in the advice they provide.

Why Professional Indemnity Insurance Usually Isn't Needed for Care Homes

Care providers aren't advisory businesses.

Their role is to deliver care, support and supervision, rather than provide professional advice that clients rely on when making financial or commercial decisions.

Because of this, the majority of claims made against care providers relate to:

  • Alleged negligence
  • Medication errors
  • Injury to residents
  • Accidents
  • Safeguarding issues
  • Clinical or care delivery concerns
  • Care Planning errors*

With the exception of care planning errors, these risks are not typically covered under professional indemnity insurance. Instead, they're insured through specialist Medical Malpractice and Treatment Liability cover, alongside other core insurance policies designed specifically for the care sector.

Care planning errors themselves can also be covered under Medical Malpractice/Treatment Liability policies, so cover for this risk may sit under either professional indemnity or malpractice cover depending on how the policy is structured. Where professional indemnity cover doesn't exist or doesn't respond, these Medical Malpractice and Treatment Liability policies can respond instead, providing an important backstop for the care provider.

Which Insurance Policies Are Most Important for Care Providers?

Rather than focusing on professional indemnity insurance, providers should ensure they have appropriate protection in place for the risks they face every day.

Medical Malpractice Insurance

One of the most important covers for any care provider.

It protects against claims arising from the delivery of care, including:

  • Medication errors
  • Alleged negligence
  • Injury during treatment or care
  • Clinical mistakes
  • Public Liability Insurance

Protects your organisation if a visitor, contractor or member of the public suffers injury or property damage connected with your business.

Employers' Liability Insurance

A legal requirement for most employers.

It protects your organisation if an employee becomes injured or develops an illness as a result of their work.

Property Insurance

Protects buildings, contents and other physical assets against risks such as fire, flood, storm damage and malicious damage.

Cyber Insurance

As care providers increasingly rely on electronic care records, medication systems and digital technology, cyber insurance has become an increasingly important consideration.

When Might Professional Indemnity Insurance Be Appropriate?

Although uncommon, there are situations where professional indemnity insurance may become relevant.

For example, if your organisation also provides:

  • Consultancy services
  • Compliance advice
  • Training to other organisations
  • Operational consultancy
  • Independent assessments

then professional indemnity insurance may be worth considering alongside your existing insurance programme.

The important point is that the need for PI depends on the services being provided, not simply the fact that you operate within the care sector.

Why Reviewing Your Insurance Regularly Matters

The care sector has evolved significantly over recent years.

Providers are adopting new technologies, expanding services and responding to increasing regulatory expectations.

As organisations grow, their insurance arrangements should evolve too.

Regular reviews help ensure your cover reflects:

  • New services
  • Additional locations
  • Increased resident numbers
  • Greater use of digital technology
  • Changing regulatory expectations
  • Inflation and rebuilding costs

Having the right insurance isn't about buying more policies, it's about making sure the protection you have reflects the risks your organisation actually faces.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is professional indemnity insurance compulsory for care homes?

No. For most care providers, professional indemnity insurance is not a legal requirement and is not typically the most appropriate cover.

What insurance does a care home need?

Most care providers should consider Employers' Liability, Public Liability, Medical Malpractice, Property Insurance and, increasingly, Cyber Insurance. The exact requirements will depend on the services provided.

Does medical malpractice insurance replace professional indemnity insurance?

For most care providers, Medical Malpractice insurance is designed to respond to claims arising from the delivery of care, making it far more relevant than professional indemnity insurance.

How do I know if my insurance is suitable?

A specialist insurance broker with experience in the care sector can review your current arrangements and ensure your cover reflects your organisation's specific risks.

How Quality Care Group Can Help

At Quality Care Group, we specialise exclusively in the care sector.

That means we understand the unique risks care providers face and can help ensure your insurance programme reflects the way your organisation operates today—not how it looked several years ago.

Whether you're reviewing your current insurance, expanding your services or simply want reassurance that you have the right protection in place, our specialists are here to help.

Start the Conversation

Insurance should give you confidence, not uncertainty.

If you'd like to review your current cover or discuss whether your insurance programme reflects your organisation's risks, speak to the team at Quality Care Group today.

Back to all news