News & Insights

Managing Summer Annual Leave Fairly: Practical Tips for Care Providers

Alan Ford

13/8/2026

Business Efficiency

How Can Care Providers Manage Summer Holiday Requests Fairly?

Summer is one of the busiest periods for annual leave requests.

School holidays, family commitments and warmer weather mean many employees want time off during the same few weeks. For care providers, balancing these requests with safe staffing levels and continuity of care can be challenging.

While annual leave is an important part of employee wellbeing, approving too many requests at once can place additional pressure on colleagues, affect service delivery and increase the reliance on agency staff.

Having a clear and consistent approach helps organisations balance operational needs with employee expectations.

Review Your Annual Leave Policy Before Peak Holiday Season

Before summer begins, it's worth reviewing your annual leave policy to ensure it remains fit for purpose.

Employees should clearly understand:

  • How much notice is required
  • How holiday requests should be submitted
  • How competing requests are managed
  • Whether there are limits on the number of employees who can be off at the same time
  • How decisions are communicated

Just as importantly, managers should apply the policy consistently across the organisation.

Have a Fair Process for Overlapping Holiday Requests

One of the most common challenges is when several employees request the same dates.

There isn't one correct approach, but whichever system you use should be transparent and applied consistently.

Many organisations choose:

  • First come, first served
  • Rotating priority each year
  • Considering previous holiday patterns
  • Departmental staffing requirements

The key is ensuring employees understand how decisions are made before requests become an issue.

Keep Resident Care at the Centre of Planning

Unlike many sectors, care providers cannot simply reduce service levels during busy holiday periods.

When approving leave, managers should consider:

  • Safe staffing levels
  • Skill mix across each shift
  • Registered Manager availability
  • Medication competency
  • Senior cover
  • Continuity of care for residents and clients

Forward planning helps reduce the need for last-minute rota changes or agency cover.

Avoid Making Assumptions

Managers naturally want to support employees wherever possible.

However, deciding whose holiday is "more important" can unintentionally create perceptions of unfairness.

Whether requests relate to school holidays, weddings or other personal commitments, decisions should always be based on established processes and business needs rather than individual circumstances wherever possible.

Consistency helps build trust.

Encourage Employees to Book Early

The earlier holiday requests are submitted, the easier they are to manage.

Many care providers remind employees several months before the summer period begins to encourage early planning.

This gives managers greater visibility of:

  • Staffing gaps
  • Training requirements
  • Shift planning
  • Recruitment needs
  • Agency cover requirements

Early planning often reduces competing requests later in the year.

Use Technology to Simplify Leave Management

Managing annual leave through spreadsheets or email chains can quickly become difficult.

Modern HR systems allow organisations to:

  • View remaining holiday entitlement
  • Track requests electronically
  • Monitor team availability
  • Identify staffing gaps
  • Improve transparency for both employees and managers

For organisations managing multiple services or locations, digital systems can significantly reduce administration while improving visibility.

Communicate Decisions Clearly

Not every holiday request can be approved.

However, employees are generally more understanding when decisions are communicated promptly and supported by a clear explanation.

Where possible, managers should explain why a request cannot be accommodated and discuss alternative dates where appropriate.

Open communication helps reduce frustration and supports positive employee relationships.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an employer refuse annual leave?

Yes. Employers can refuse holiday requests where there is a legitimate business reason, provided they comply with the employee's contract and the Working Time Regulations.

Should requests always be approved on a first come, first served basis?

Not necessarily. Some organisations operate alternative systems, provided they are fair, transparent and applied consistently.

How many employees should be allowed off at once?

This depends on the size of the organisation and the level of cover required to maintain safe staffing and service delivery.

Should annual leave policies be reviewed regularly?

Yes. Reviewing policies each year helps ensure they continue to support both operational requirements and employee wellbeing.

How Quality Care Group Can Help

Supporting care providers goes beyond insurance.

Through our trusted HR partners, Quality Care Group can help organisations review employment policies, strengthen HR processes and access practical advice on managing workforce challenges.

Whether you're reviewing your annual leave policy, updating employee handbooks or looking for day-to-day HR support, we're here to help.

Start the Conversation

If you'd like to learn more about the HR support available through Quality Care Group, speak to our Business Solutions team today.

Together with our trusted HR partners, we can help you build practical people policies that support your organisation, your employees and the people in your care.

Back to all news